In our
life circle there are many people in which we associate ourselves with, people
in which we have a relationship. Not referring
to just two people in love or dating as our view of a relationship, but the way
in which an individual relates to another. Ishiguro uses setting and symbolism to show
how a relationship is affected when means by which the associations forming the
relationship are dissolved. All of the
Hailsham students share a common bond on the simple association of having
attended Hailsham. We get this feeling
early on when Kathy states, “I started seeking out for my donors people from
the past, and whenever I could, people from Hailsham”(5). Now that she has been allowed to choose her
own donors to care for she begins to seek out those who she can relate to. Her closeness to Ruth was a result of,
according to Kathy, “the fact that we’d grown up together at Hailsham” (5). Hailsham became a place where the students
could form relationships from their experiences while attending Hailsham. Unlike the other donor who relish the memories
and ties Kathy and the other Hailsham students had, Kathy and the others took
solace in the place that gave them such memories. Hailsham as a “boarding school” had provided
a place for the clones to be reared as close to normal children as
possible. By Hailsham being a place for
the student to feeling interact allowed for the formation of relationships one
with another. This becomes most evident
when we learn of the closing of Hailsham.
Kathy compares a handful of balloons held by a clown to the individuals
of Hailsham and with the news of the closing, “it was like someone coming along
with a pair of shears and snipping the balloon string just where they entwined
above the man’s fist. Once this happened
there’d be no real sense in which those balloons belonged with each other anymore”
(213). With Hailsham gone so was the tie
in which all Hailsham student had been linked one with another. Left to just memories of what it was like we
see a fading in their relationship that reflect the dissolved associations that
Hailsham once brought. This is evident
in the conversation Kathy has with Laura, walking by Laura Kathy states, “I was
tempted to ignore her and keep walking” (209).
Laura was a close friend of Kathy’s while at Hailsham, and with their
conversation being very dull and since leaving Hailsham and its closing, the
desire to remember or talk about Hailsham appears burdensome, Kathy states, “Maybe
we both felt there was something dangerous about bringing up the old days,
because for ages we avoided any mention of hem” (209). Later we see a distancing of even the closest
friends: Kathy, Ruth, and Tommy following the departure of Hailsham. Little by little as they have left the place
that brought them such memories and all it stood for, their ability to relate
to one another fell upon their current state, which state only moved them away
from each other.
Long post! I like the interpretation of the students sort of being forced to befriend one another. Or...did I read into that the wrong way? That was what I took out of your comments on them seeking out other Hailsham students! Hehe.
ReplyDeleteI remember us watching the movie and at one point thinking that Kathy really shouldn't have been Ruth's best friend. Kathy was such a loner, and I got the impression that Ruth sort of needed Kathy in order to deal with her daily life. During the Cottages, in the movie, she was overly critical (and kind of a bitch) to Kathy but then later on comes in to make amends and ask for help about her "original".
I can't say I agreed with the way Kathy used the balloon symbolism in regards to Hailsham closing. I like how YOU use it, but I think it's kind of overly dramatic to act like that in a situation. "Without Hailsham we have no common ground!" Like...really? What about all those years that you played together in the sandbox, took classes together, shared each other's secrets, held each other, etc etc?
Maybe Ishiguro was attempting to get us to realize just how much of a crutch things were in their lives, though. Like, Kathy felt completely at a loss knowing that Hailsham was shut down ya know? Just a maybe!
Great stuff, Keifer!